Guide top › Comparisons › Shirogami vs Aogami
Shirogami vs Aogami
Proterial's white and blue paper steels: purity against a measured dose of alloy.
Both are Yasugi carbon steels from the same mill. Shirogami is iron and carbon with minimal alloying; aogami adds chromium (0.2–0.5%) and tungsten (1.0–2.0%) to the same carbon ladder.
In use: shirogami sharpens fastest and takes the finest edge; aogami keeps its edge longer and takes more work on the stone. Both rust. Grade numbers (#1, #2) mark carbon content in both families.
| Shirogami | Aogami | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon (No.2 grade) | 1.05–1.15% | 1.05–1.15% |
| Alloy additions | Minimal | Cr 0.2–0.5%, W 1.0–1.5% (No.2) |
| Edge retention | Good | Better (tungsten carbides) |
| Sharpening speed | Faster | Slower |
| Rust | Yes — carbon steel | Yes — carbon steel |
Which tasks each suits
- Sharpening-led cooks and traditional single-bevel users lean shirogami.
- Cooks who prioritise intervals between sharpenings lean aogami — accepting slower sessions when they come.
This comparison states facts drawn from the linked records. It is not a test result and not a ranking.